Metal Detector or Magnetic Separator?

By buntingeurope | 06 October 2016

5 Key Questions to Ask Before Making a Decision

There is a metal contamination issue that needs addressing and the conclusion is that either a Magnetic Separator or a Metal Detector will solve the problem.  So, before a purchase is made, what key questions have to be asked?

Metal Detector or Magnetic Separator?

Broken Spanner

  1. Why is the metal contamination an issue? This may sound like an odd question, but why has this issue suddenly become a burning problem?  Is it because the metal has damaged other equipment or is it because the metal has ended up in the end product either just before or after being supplied to the customer?
  2. What and how big is the metal contamination? Metal contamination can occur in many forms:
    • Large sized metal items include spanners, screwdrivers, broken pieces of other equipment and even mobile phones;
    • Medium sized metal items include nuts, bolts, nails and pieces of damaged pumps,
    • Small metal such as shards from a broken screen, pins and fragments from worn equipment;
    • Fine and very fine metal contamination that occurs from worn processing equipment, especially when processing hard materials such as cocoa beans;
  3. Is the metal magnetic or non-magnetic? Oddly enough, some ‘non-magnetic’ metals such as stainless steel can become very weakly magnetic if they are work hardened.  The edges of stainless steel bolts are often weakly magnetic, as is fine stainless steel originating from the wear of processing equipment;
  4. What is the extent of the metal contamination issue? Very often the issue will only be raised when either a customer complains, a key item of processing equipment is damaged or a batch of product is rejected by internal quality control.  However, finding such metal contamination once means that it is highly likely that there is metal passing through the system undetected;
  5. How much does and could the metal contamination problem cause the business? Sometimes this is difficult to calculate as how much is a damaged reputation worth?  If an item of equipment is damaged, then it is easy to put a figure on the repair or replacement cost, but what about lost production and the associated labour costs?

What Is The Solution?

Unfortunately, addressing and solving a metal contamination issue is not as simple as just installing one item of equipment, whether it is a Magnetic Separator or Metal Detector.

metal detector and magnetic separator

A Magnetic Separator may not capture a larger stainless steel item, whereas the Metal Detector will not be useful when trying to remove fine or very fine metal.  Also, there are the practicalities of installation to consider, with space and the process being key issues.  The only way to correctly determine what is needed is to undertake a full review of the process, assessing critical areas and the potential sources of the contamination will result in a complete and robust solution.

So as to the original question, the answer is that it is highly likely that both a Magnetic Separator and Metal Detector will be required, located at different points within the process for very specific objectives.

For more information or a site review by our trained sales engineers, please contact us on:

Phone:  01442 875081


Via the website

Facebook Circular